Papaya Global: Best for international manufacturers

Our star rating: 4.2 out of 5

As a global payroll solution, Papaya supports running payroll and paying employees in more than 160 countries. Its AI-powered platform stays up to date on employment in every country and automatically flags you on potential compliance issues. The payroll software also integrates smoothly with the most important (and most popular) global business technologies for manufacturers, including QuickBooks Online, Expensify, BambooHR and more.

For more information, read our Papaya Global review.

Pricing

Papaya Global only charges a per-employee monthly fee, not a base fee along with a per-employee fee. However, you pay for each Papaya service separately. If you want payroll and health benefits, for instance, you’ll pay for both Full-Service Payroll and Global Expertise Services:

• Full-Service Payroll starts at $12 a month per payee and works best for manufacturing businesses with three to 20 locations.
• Payments-as-a-Service starts at $3 a month per employee and lets you pay workers across the world.
• Contractor Management starts at $2 a month per contractor.
• A Data and Insights Platform License starts at $150 a month per location (not per employee) and lets you generate payroll reports for your business.
• Global Expertise Services start at $190 a month per employee and enables you to find global health plans and other employee benefits.

Features

• Automatic payroll tax calculation and filing in 160+ countries.
• Payments in local currencies delivered no more than 72 hours after you run payroll.
• Self-service mobile app for employees to access payroll data, request PTO and more.
• Professional white-glove software setup for new clients.
• The option to continue working with your current payroll provider on the Papaya OS.
• Access to templates, local compliance experts and legislation notifications to keep companies abreast of employment law changes across the globe.
• GDPR-compliant data security measures.

Pros

• Papaya’s global team of on-the-ground legal experts — including health and safety experts — keeps you informed and compliant with local laws.
• Country-specific benefits are customized to keep you competitive.
• Papaya’s platform simplifies paperwork filing for immigration and visas to make hiring expats as simple as possible.

Cons

• Papaya Global’s reporting package is higher than the base price for typical payroll providers that offer built-in reporting with each plan.
• Invoicing is a separate feature that isn’t fully automated with the Papaya Global system.

Gusto: Most time-saving automations

Our star rating: 4.6 out of 5

Gusto’s fully automated software combines basic HR elements (benefits, healthcare and workers’ comp administration) with full-service payroll. Businesses can set payroll to run automatically so employees never miss a pay day. Payroll syncs instantly with time and attendance data to give you accurate, up-to-date payroll data.

Gusto includes several features for free that many manufacturing payroll services don’t (for instance, mailing out end-of-year tax forms), which makes it a good pick for small and midsize businesses operating on a strict payroll budget.

For more information, read our Gusto payroll review.

Pricing

Gusto’s three plans have increasing levels of HR features and support to make Gusto scalable for growing businesses:

• Simple starts at $40 per month plus $6 per payee per month.
• Plus starts at $80 per month plus $12 per payee per month.
• Premium has customized pricing only.

Gusto doesn’t advertise a free trial, though it does offer a free demo, free quote and occasional discounts for first-time users. If you set up an account for free, you won’t have to pay for Gusto until your first payroll run.

Features

• Unlimited automatic payroll runs with automatic direct deposit in all 50 U.S. states.
• Automatic wage garnishment and remittance (available everywhere but South Carolina).
• Onboarding checklists, personalized offer letter templates and secure e-document signing and storage.
• Unique benefits options like commuter travel allowances and college savings funds.
• ACA, HIPAA and ERISA compliance support from Gusto’s legal experts.
• Compliance alerts (available with premium plan only).

Pros

• No extra charge to integrate workers’ compensation insurance and healthcare benefits found through Gusto’s brokerage.
• Base fee waived for six months for manufacturing businesses that pay contractors only.
• Custom admin permissions keep sensitive data secure.
• Payroll can be set to autopilot so you don’t have to actively run payroll.

Cons

• Health benefits are only available in 37 U.S. states plus Washington, D.C.
• Gusto lets you pay international contractors but not international employees.
• No mobile payroll app for employers (employees can clock in and out with Gusto Wallet).
• Built-in time and project tracking are not available with Gusto’s cheapest plan.

ADP RUN: Best HR solutions for midsize companies

Our star rating: 4.4 out of 5

ADP is a payroll and HR management company that operates globally. Along with its more sweeping professional employer organization (PEO) solutions for businesses that want to turn workforce management over to a third party, it offers combined payroll and HR software, including its popular RUN Powered by ADP payroll product.

Manufacturing businesses can use RUN to pay employees in 140+ countries. Each RUN plan also includes HR features like basic HR tips, newsletters and checkups.

For more information, read our RUN Powered by ADP review.

Pricing

ADP doesn’t list pricing for any of its manufacturing payroll plans online. Interested businesses will have to contact ADP’s sales team directly for a customized quote. However, its site does include feature information for all four RUN ADP plans:

• Essential Payroll includes basic payroll features like automatic direct deposit, tax filing and state new-hire reporting.
• Enhanced Payroll adds secure check signing, automatic wage garnishment and background checks on new employees.
• Complete Payroll adds employee onboarding, HR forms and HR compliance alerts.
• HR Pro adds thorough legal compliance services and personalized HR support.

ADP typically offers three months free to new customers with every plan.

Features

• Automatic payroll runs and direct deposit in 140+ countries.
• General ledger integration.
• Automatic new-hire state reporting.
• Access to legally required state and federal employment forms.
• Thorough payroll and workforce reports with every plan.
• Mobile payroll app for employers to run payroll away from the office.
• Mobile app for employees to clock in and out, check pay stubs and request time off.

Pros

• Payroll and workforce reports included with no extra fee.
• Compliance database makes it easy for businesses to stay informed on federal and state employment laws.
• Thousands of legally compliant HR forms, templates and best-practice documents available to download and customize.

Cons

• Legal compliance alerts only available with the priciest plan.
• Basic onboarding tasks not included with cheaper plans.
• Additional fee for W-2 and 1099 tax form generation.

Paycor: Best HCM solution

Our star rating: 3.9 out of 5

Human capital management solutions like Paycor tackle everything related to managing your employees, starting with payroll, HR and time tracking. Paycor’s software also guides you through every phase of finding, hiring and retaining employees, which includes processes like recruiting, scheduling, benefits, career mapping, employee development and more.

Paycor offers industry-specific onboarding for clients in the manufacturing industry. A customer service rep well-versed in employment issues specific to manufacturers — for instance, managing seasonal workers, staying in compliance and handling workers’ comp — will help set up and customize Paycor’s manufacturing payroll software to your company’s needs.

For more information, read our full Paycor review.

Pricing

Paycor doesn’t list the pricing for its four plans online, though it does advertise 50% off for your first year and waives all setup fees.

• Paycor Basic includes automatic payroll runs and focuses on tax compliance.
• Paycor Essential adds more compliance and HR support to Basic’s payroll features.
• Paycor Core adds career management and other employee-support features.
• Paycor Complete, Paycor’s most comprehensive plan, adds compensation planning and talent development.

Features

• Automatic federal and state payroll tax deduction and remittance.
• Multiple employee payment options, including direct deposit and check.
• Employee self-service portal.
• HR templates, legal compliance alerts and how-to payroll and HR guides.
• Detailed analytic reports, including compensation analysis, diversity and inclusion insights and employee turnover metrics.

Pros

• Payroll runs can be scheduled in advance and made automatic.
• Paycor monitors employment law at the state, federal, county and city levels and sends alerts to keep you compliant.
• Proactive, predictive analytic reports help you understand how your employees feel about your business to help improve retention.

Cons

• Customizable plans may be too expensive for small and midsize businesses.
• Limited third-party integrations might necessitate redundant data entry as you hop between software programs.

QuickBooks Payroll: Best for small manufacturing businesses

Our star rating: 4.1 out of 5

If you’re already using Intuit QuickBooks Online as your company’s cloud-based accounting solution, adding QuickBooks Payroll is basically painless. Your payroll and accounting data will sync automatically, ensuring your books always reflect the most accurate employee pay. QuickBooks has a notably low learning curve, so if you’re used to QuickBooks but new to payroll, learning to use QuickBooks Payroll will take you the least amount of time compared to any other payroll solution.

If you run a multi-state enterprise, QuickBooks offers several industry-specific accounting solutions via its QuickBooks Desktop Enterprise product. QuickBooks Desktop syncs with QuickBooks Desktop Payroll, not the cloud-based QuickBooks Online version of payroll, and can be harder to operate remotely.

For more information, read our full QuickBooks Payroll review.

Pricing

QuickBooks Online Payroll has three payroll plans.

• Core starts at $45 a month plus $6 per employee.
• Premium starts at $80 a month plus $8 per employee.
• Elite starts at $125 a month plus $10 per employee.

As with its accounting software, new QuickBooks Payroll users can choose between a 30-day free trial or 50% off for three months.

Features

• Automatic payroll tax remittance plus up to $25,000 worth of tax penalty protection (most expensive plan only).
• Automatic payroll runs and direct deposit.
• Workers’ compensation integration with automated premium payment.
• Next-day or same-day direct deposit (dependent on plan).
• Shift or job schedule creation via employee-facing mobile app.
• Real-time notifications for employee scheduling changes.

Pros

• Next-day and same-day direct deposit ensure employees get paid quickly.
• Automatic payroll runs take the task of manually running payroll off your plate.
• Straightforward integration with QuickBooks Online.

Cons

• No free workers’ compensation integration with Core plan.
• Integration limited to QuickBooks family of products.
• High monthly base prices.

Rippling: Best customizations

Our star rating: 4.3 out of 5

If you want to build a completely unique manufacturing payroll solution from the ground up, Rippling’s business model could work best for you. Along with payroll, Rippling offers benefits administration, HR, learning management, time and attendance, applicant tracking and employee survey modules. You can choose however many modules you want to create a customized business software package and only pay for the tools you need.

For more information, read our full Rippling payroll review.

Pricing

Rippling advertises its starting payroll price as $8 per person per month. Users also pay an unspecific monthly base fee to use Rippling’s operating system, Rippling Unity. Contact Rippling directly for a more accurate quote.

Features

• Global payroll.
• Employee pay options in multiple currencies.
• Real-time HR compliance alerts.
• Global expense management, including employee expense tracking.
• Employee reimbursement in multiple currencies.
• Domestic PEO service and global Employer of Record service.
• Pre-made compliance courses for national and international employees.
• Time and attendance software with mobile and kiosk clock-in options.

Pros

• Essential payroll, HR, IT, finance and employee development tasks are all managed on one unified platform.
• Holiday calendars, benefits, equity and time-off policies can all be customized for workers in different countries.
• Automated, built-in compliance enforces minimum wage, overtime, employee leave and compliance training requirements in every country.
• Multiple employee-facing features like surveys, onboarding and feedback opportunities gives employees more insight into employee job satisfaction and retention rates.

Cons

• Limited transparent pricing online.
• Potentially high software learning curve for new users.

Rippling is currently offering a 30-day free subscription to TechRepublic readers. Follow the link below to sign up.